Is Politeness Killing Productivity

Image: An open book with the heading "Productivity" against a blurry background of grass.

New Zealanders are polite folks. It’s something we’re a little bit proud of. We’d sooner eat a meal we don’t like than complain to the restaurant that we didn’t get what we ordered. We’d rather sit at a busy roundabout waiting for all of the cars. And we’d rather fix our staff members mistakes ourselves instead of talking to them about their performance… But is politeness killing productivity?

Productivity has been a source of concern for The Treasury, New Zealand government’s lead economic advisor, for some time. While generally trends in New Zealand follow those in other developed economies, according to the OECD we rank 26th out of 37 countries. Not exactly exciting.

Why does productivity matter? Well we’re a small country a long way from anywhere, so we have to work harder to compete on the global stage. Our goods have to travel further, and we import a lot of the products New Zealanders expect, with an economy heavily dependent on primary produce and services.

There are all sorts of potential economic reasons why this might be the case. We are a bit cheap – we tend to wait until things are broken before we replace them, and we have a tendency to value ingenuity over infrastructure investment… she’ll be right, after all.

But what if even a portion of our national productivity issues stem from being too nice to say anything that might hurt somebody’s feelings. What if our politeness is killing our productivity?

Image: Two hands pointing at a computer screen. Is politeness killing productivity?

Six Ways Politeness Kills Productivity

Civility and respect in the workplace are really important, but there are some areas where we mistake this for not having a tough conversation that needs to happen, afraid perhaps that we’ll be accused of being a bully or that we might hurt someone’s feelings.

Or that they might not like us afterwards.

Failure to Provide Timely Constructive Criticism

Learning anything new or difficult means making mistakes. Whether we are new to our jobs, or stretching into responsibilities that we haven’t had before, getting it wrong and having someone help us figure out how to do it differently next time, are generally seen as critical for making progress.

But what about when you’ve been in the role for a while? Are others still so willing to provide a corrective nudge or critical feedback?

I’ve noticed two things about feedback.

The first is that many managers don’t want to provide constructive criticism when someone is new because the relationship is still forming… we don’t necessarily trust each other yet, and we want to be liked.

The second is something of a paradox… if you leave it to late to provide feedback it becomes harder and harder to raise it, because we’re embarrassed that we didn’t say anything when the issue first emerged. We keep hoping it will go away on its own, when instead, it gets worse and worse.

Delayed Decision-making

We really do prefer to be liked, and while we know making tough calls comes with the territory, we would rather not. If we don’t have to.

That means we wait. We hope the problem will go away on its own. This is particularly true in relation to performance issues with staff we manage. We leave the problem for as long as we possibly can – all the while the impact of poor performance is demoralising and frustrating others in our team.

Being too polite can also mean we spend a lot of time trying to arrive (as if by magic) at consensus. We don’t want to make the call that annoys others, or we worry that they will think we don’t value their opinion.

I have seen programmes of work continue long after the leadership assumes it has been stopped because nobody had the heart to pull the plug and tell the team.

In all of these cases, a lot of unproductive time goes into avoiding the tough call – to exit the staff member, to make the unpopular decision, to override the objectives of colleagues.

Increased Stress Levels and Burnout

When you aren’t expressing your true feelings for fear of upsetting someone else, it means you are holding in your frustrations and ‘putting up with’ things that you’d prefer not to. If everything else about your role and job is going along swimmingly, this probably won’t matter too much, but if it is one of several stressors, it can soon mount up.

Being too polite to raise something may mean you’re personally taking on responsibilities that should rest with someone else, it could mean that you are having to find work-arounds or maintain ineffective processes that need to be improved.

It may also mean that you have trouble switching off, with all the things you wish you had said playing in a loop in your mind when you should be spending time with family and friends.

If this goes on too long, the impact on your health and wellbeing can be significant.

Lack of Innovation

When Google carried out “Operation Aristotle” to understand the factors that lead to high-performing teams, they identified psychological safety as a key component – a foundational component – without which teams couldn’t reach the lofty heights of high performance.

Unfortunately, psychological safety has become a highly used, even ubiquitous term, where many aren’t using it correctly. It doesn’t mean an environment where we get everything our own way, and where no one corrects us or challenges us and we feel happy all the time. It means an environment where team members feel comfortable sharing their opinions, ideas, and feedback without fear of retribution or rejection. This requires vulnerability and willingness to make mistakes.

However, in an environment where we are worried about hurting others’ feelings or ‘rocking the boat’ we are unlikely to put our innovative ideas and suggestions out there. Productivity suffers, and the best employees don’t stick around.

Avoidance of Conflict

Most people reading that heading, especially fellow Kiwi, likely believe that conflict is supposed to be avoided. We tend to assume conflict is bad.

At our core, human beings prefer the status quo. We like things to be, well, just the way they are. Conflict is a necessary precursor to change, and so at the first sign of conflict, we react like an immune system to the first signs of a flu virus. We stomp on it, in the hope we can prevent it from taking hold.

Without change, though, productivity stays exactly the same. In fact, for some businesses, failure to engage in healthy levels of conflict leads to stagnation and ultimately irrelevance. So while national rates of productivity remain static, that means individual businesses and organisations are floundering and failing.

Engaging in healthy conflict is essential to growth.

Miscommunication

In an effort to be polite, we can fall into the trap of making our message ambiguous. We remove all the clarity and fail to actually communicate. Vague language can ensure you don’t upset anyone… but it also means that nobody knows what you actually want.

I have witnessed numerous situations where teams are at cross-purposes about the goal of their project, or multiple people think they are leading the same work. I have seen many ‘multi-headed hydra’ projects where there is more than one business owner or more than one governance group ‘overseeing’ the work so that key stakeholders feel important. I’ve seen people added to programme boards who should be on advisory groups.

The miscommunication that emerges from these situations often presents as ‘interpersonal’ conflict, but seldom are. More often it is because there is lack of clarity about goals, roles or processes.

Concluding Thoughts

In general, we assume that being polite is the same as being kind. We err on the side of not stepping on toes or hurting people’s feelings, often not because of them, but because of us. We don’t like the idea that we could hurt somebody. Or that they might not like us afterwards.

However, this false kindness is killing productivity, wasting people’s time and energy, and destroying our organisations from the inside out.

That doesn’t sound kind to me. It sounds like the opposite.

No responses yet

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *