In Search of Efficiency and Effectiveness…

Image: A nighttime scene with a setting sun, and swirls of light creating shapes against the darkness.

It is widely held that modern management theory emerged in 1911 when Frederick W Taylor started analysing and standardising the way that workers loaded steel onto railcars to find the ‘one best way’ to do it.

Machine as a Metaphor for Understanding Organisations

Given the prevalence of manufacturing jobs at the time, it isn’t too difficult to draw a line from Taylor’s work through to one of the dominant metaphors for what an organisation is: a machine.

We focus on inputs and outputs, we rely on ‘wiring diagrams’ to understand how they work and we assume ‘restructuring’ them will fix them when they are not working as expected.

“Organisation as a Machine” Metaphors

  • Inputs & Outputs
  • Spanner in the works
  • Well-oiled
  • Nuts and bolts
  • Put the wheels in motion
  • Running like clockwork
  • Shift gears
  • Recalibrate
  • Running smoothly
  • Lots of moving parts
  • Drilling down
  • Crank out
  • Wiring diagram
  • Running out of steam
  • Like a Production line
  • Programmed
  • Downtime

Efficiency and effectiveness are sensible aspirations if we consider our organisations to be ‘like machines’. We want to make sure that the organisation is efficiently turning our inputs into outputs, and is effective at producing ‘products’ that work.

Organism as a Metaphor for Understanding Organisations

Over the last few decades however, we have moved towards increased recognition that organisations are complex systems, and that the machine-metaphor isn’t particularly useful in helping us understand or improve how they work. This has seen the emergence of metaphors aligned with organisms, which has been helpful, and enabled new insights. We refer to adaptation, learning organisations and culture. We recognise that organisations have their own values, purpose and even immune systems.

“Organisation as an Organism” Metaphors

  • Organisational values
  • Learning organisation
  • Ecosystem
  • Survival instincts
  • Organisational behaviour
  • Operating in a dynamic environment
  • Resilience
  • Immune response
  • Organic growth
  • Nodes and networks
  • Purpose-led
  • Agile
  • Transformation
  • Relationship-based

It also saw a departure from efficiency and effectiveness as the goals of managers, HR and finance teams. We recognised that outcomes are complex and can be tricky to measure. Pursuing efficiency and effectiveness has fallen out of favour.

But this is a loss that is not justified.

We can recognise that organisations are complex dynamic systems, where how and what they produce can be difficult to standardise and predict, AND that they are capable of being efficient and effective.

The Organisation as a “Black Box”

The reality is that most of the people who work in an organisation are not aware of the way it works. People and money and time pour in, and (hopefully) useful things come out.

An image of a dark grey box, showing people, time and money going in, and services, products and culture coming out. It is unclear how the transformation occurs. The box has the words "Black Box" on it.

If the organisation were a machine, it would be plausible that we could design it to be efficient and effective at taking time and money and turning them into products and services. It is the addition of people (and with more than one person, relationships) that the organisation goes from being a machine to being a complex dynamic system that thinks and behaves in unpredictable ways. And it is this unpredictability that pushed us away from efficiency and effectiveness as useful goals in their own right.

Enter Human Resources.

When we started to refer to people as human resources we experienced a cognitive dissonance. People of course are resources… but we like to think that people are more than ‘just resources’. So we abandoned efficiency and effectiveness, and embraced the messy unpredictability of complex organisms and ecosystems. But at what cost?

Energy as a Resource

What is it that people bring to the organisation that enables it to do what it does?

I suggest that the answer is energy. The ‘human resource’ is energy. When people are engaged in their work, and have commitment to the purpose of their organisation, they are able to bring their energy and effort to bear in ways that are quite impressive.

We understand this from the perspective of the individual employee. We have a deep vein of scholarship and practice around what motivates people, and also ideas around wellbeing and burnout. We recognise that, for some people, they can exhaust themselves in their efforts at work, if that energy is not being replenished as quickly as it is being spent.

Yet we do not pay attention to whether or not the organisation is an efficient or effective recipient of its employees’ energy.

Is it worthy?

Does it treat it with respect?

Or does it waste it. Letting it leak out in unproductive ways… inefficient processes, unclear policies, lack of clarity and leadership, failure to tackle unhelpful (or even harmful) behaviours? Does it prioritise the activity that is most valued so that effort is not spent in pointless endeavours?

Managers as Stewards of Energy

If managers are able to hold the idea that money, and time, and energy are the resources that they have at their disposal, and they seek to design and build teams and systems that minimise leakage and reward energy well spent, then perhaps efficiency and effectiveness are still useful concepts.

If you have ever worked in an organisation where you feel like you work hard, but make little progress, you might know what I’m talking about. Endless hours spent in meetings where nothing seems to happen… No clarity about who can make decisions that are crucial to your work… Bureaucracy without purpose and for its own sake… Ideas and suggestions that would improve outcomes or customer experience that fall into an abyss of nothingness…

As a manager it is your responsibility to be a steward of the energy that your people entrust to you. They choose to spend it on work that is meaningful to them. And they need you to ensure that it is not a wasted investment. Watch for where the energy leaks out, and repair the leak. Make sure you share with them what you know about where their energy is most usefully directed.

And most importantly of all… don’t give up on efficiency and effectiveness. We need our organisations, and our people, to thrive and deliver their full potential.

No responses yet

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *