A Beginner’s Guide to Crafting Strategy

‘Strategic’ might be the most overused adjective in our corporate lives. Sometimes it is added as a prefix to things it really shouldn’t be… often as a way to demonstrate significance or importance. In reality, this has led to the diminishing of strategy as a tool. Today, we’ll try and cut through some of the noise and nonsense, to provide a beginner’s guide to crafting strategy. We will outline:

  • What strategy is,
  • Three components of good strategy,
  • Four common pitfalls, and
  • How to get started.

What is Strategy?

There are a lot of definitions and explanations out there. My favourite is from Dr Max Mckeown who says “strategy is achieving desirable ends with available means”. There is always a time element to strategy. It is about the future, and creating a more desirable future with a degree of intention.

It’s not complicated. But that doesn’t mean it’s simple.

In reality the future is unknowable. We can made educated guesses, and use tools like forecasting, and trend analysis, but the thing about committing to a plan is that it will be wrong. Sometimes almost immediately. The key is not to let that stop you. If you can hold it lightly, and use it as a way to guide actions and decisions, rather than predicting them, it will feel a lot more comfortable.

In essence, organisational strategy – or strategic planning, which tends to be used somewhat interchangeably – is about creating and describing a gap between where you are now and where you want to be in a certain amount of time. It’s about articulating the level of change required to get you to where you want to be. And it’s about recognising the amount of effort and resource needed to make meaningful progress. Good strategy also provides you with the posture or outlook needed to notice opportunities that you couldn’t have planned for.

Another way to put it: it’s about investing in deliberate, long-term change.

Once a strategic plan (the place where you document your strategy) comes together, it can seem really obvious, especially if lots of people have been involved in the process. Strategy is a team sport, after all. But the distance from the beginning to the end can stretch out like a long and winding road.

We find our clients tend to fall into a few different camps when it comes to strategy and strategic planning.

Camp A is made up of people who know that having a strategy is important (they’ve heard people talking about it in tones of hushed significance) but have no idea what one is or where to start.

Camp B who have seen and read strategic plans before and reckon they could give it a crack, but feel a bit intimidated.

Camp C is filled with people who know exactly what to do, but they’re pretty rare. If you have one in your organisation, cherish them!

Camp D people think strategic planning is a waste of time. They’ve likely experienced bad strategy one time too often and are now just getting on with what they think is required. We’re not going to win them over today.

Components of Good Strategy

If we boil it right down, there are three things a strategic plan must include:

  • An honest appraisal of where you are right now,
  • A clear and compelling description of where you want to go, and
  • A realistic story about how you might get there.

If any one of these components is missing, you cease to have a strategy.

No Dead Reckoning

I’ve seen many glossy corporate documents that paint an incredibly vivid picture of where an organisation wants to be in five or ten year’s time. It might even include a few high profile projects or initiatives that need to be delivered. But in the absence of an honest appraisal of where you are right now, how will you ever know if you are making progress, or whether the proposed actions are taking you in the right direction. This is like identifying a destination on a map, agreeing to head west, but having no idea of your current location.

No North Star

Many organisations are realistic about their current state, and have a very busy portfolio of programmes and projects to deliver. In fact this is likely to be ‘status quo’ for many organisations. In the absence of a clear and compelling shared vision for the future, many of these activities will be well intentioned but pulling in competing directions. These organisations also lack any useful framework for deciding what to do (and what not to do). As a former boss of mine liked to say “if you don’t know where you’re going, any road will get you there”. Staff in organisations like this often become frustrated or disengaged because they observe decisions and activities that appear to contradict their own idea of what the strategy is.

No Commitment

When an organisation has a compelling vision and an honest sense of where it is, but hasn’t refined its work programme to match, the implication is that the ‘strategy’ is purely window dressing. These are typically the ones that get shelved because they seem unrealistic. The role of leaders and managers is to fill this vacuum with a clear sense that the gap is able to be closed through innovation and implementation of work programmes that are designed with the end in mind.

Common Pitfalls

Getting Tangled in Definitions

One person’s strategy is another person’s plan… and everyone thinks their definition is the right definition. There are often strategies within strategies, so quite a lot of checking that we are all operating at the same level of magnification (or zoom-outed-ness) is really important. Strategy can occur within a business function, team or project AND it can occur for an entire organisation, system or market. The usefulness of the strategic thinking gets lost if you regularly zoom in and out – you need to agree the level of strategy and stick with that. Don’t stress too much about what ‘strategic’ means. Calibrate your level of zoom, check it from time to time and crack on!

Chasing Perfection

There is no such thing as a perfect strategy. Near enough is good enough. In fact a strategy is simply a lens through which to make decisions and evaluate options. You do not need to anticipate every possible outcome, or describe every aspect of your desired future state. Crucially, you shouldn’t even try to describe all the steps required to get there – pursuing your strategic goals is more like orienteering than using your satnav. After each step, you need to reassess your North Star and your dead reckoning.

In practice, this means that you can set out your first steps/actions in your strategic plan, but the further ahead you look, the less certainty you should have.

Going Alone

I know that ‘buy-in’ is one of those horrible corporate jargon phrases that is so last century, but it is true that you will have more commitment to your strategic plan – and the effort required to deliver it – if you involve more people in creating it. The golden rule here is to be clear about what people can contribute to, and what they can’t. Manage the expectations of participants carefully. Be specific about who gets to make the final decision. Involve as broad a range of stakeholders as you can: employees, clients, suppliers, owners, community groups. It needs to be relevant to them, obviously, but err on the side of inclusion. Strategy is a team sport. Give people the option to get involved – not everyone will take it, but they still like to be invited.

Sugar-coating It

If you paint a rosy happy glowing picture of your current state when your staff are unhappy and disengaged, or your clients think that your service sucks, or your suppliers are destroying the environment to create the goods your purchase from them, then nobody will believe you when you say you have a plan to make things better.

If you downplay the scale of the change required to achieve the strategy because you are worried that you will spook your team, or investors, or the government, you will never be able to achieve what you set out to do.

You don’t have to be self-deprecating and pitiful, but you do need to be honest.

Where to begin…?

So we know what it is, and we know what not to do. But where do we actually start?

Gather Perspectives on What Is… and What Could Be

Our process begins with one-to-one discussions with a range of key stakeholders. Senior staff, board members, the leadership team, subject matter experts… This list is informed by who will make decisions on the strategy and then by collecting more names when I hold the first discussions. The question I’m seeking to answer is: “who cares?”

When I meet with people I ask them questions about how they think the organisation (or team or programme) is doing now. Then I ask them what good would look like. Having done this a few times, I have a pretty good nose for which threads of the conversation to pull on, and which ones to leave alone. When I uncover a particularly novel or even radical idea in a conversation, I explore how much that view is likely to be shared, and what potential opposition might exist. These conversations tend to last about 45 minutes, and I always finish with “and is there anything else you wanted to share with me?”. It’s amazing how many of the most compelling ideas about strategy come from responses to this question!

There will also be data to support or refute these perspectives. Employee engagement, financial performance, non-financial performance, market research, existing plans and strategies.

Once this is all collected, there is a need to synthesis the information into some key themes. While it is technically plausible that there might not be any themes, I’ve never found this to be the case.

Common themes include:

  • Who we need to be, compared with who we are now
  • What we need to do, compared with what we do now
  • Who we need to have relationships with, compared with who we have relationships with now
  • What we need to value or prioritise, compared with what we value or prioritise now
  • What we need to recognise or reward, compared with what we recognise or reward now
  • The impact we need to have, compared with the impact we have now

Once these themes have emerged and you have articulated them as clearly as you can, you need to test your thinking with decision makers and key stakeholders.

In practice, crafting strategy is iterative. You may have to loop around more than once. Some things will resonate, while others won’t. That’s ok. Don’t rush it. You want to find the most compelling three to five themes for expansion.

Create a Tension Between ‘This’ and ‘That’

I often describe these ‘themes’ as strategic shifts. From ‘this’ to ‘that’. This makes it easier to commence the process of exploring what it would take to close the gap, and why it matters. This gap needs to be exciting and a little bit scary. It needs to inspire people to get involved. It needs to be something that we want to work for. The energy that comes from this tension is really important. Without it, nothing is likely to change.

Sketch out the First-Next Steps

In each area where a ‘strategic shift’ has been identified, the organisation needs to identify a small number of practical initiatives or investments that start to close the gap. There are some good questions you can ask to help identify these activities:

  • What do organisations that look like we want to in the future have in common?
  • What are we currently doing that the future organisation wouldn’t do or would do very differently?
  • What would it feel like to work in that organisation and why?
  • How could we demonstrate our commitment to becoming more like that future organisation?
  • What habits (ways of working) and behaviours would be visible to someone new to the organisation?

Obviously you can also design questions that are very specific to the shifts you are creating.

Document it!

Unless you write it down, it will exist in everybody’s heads as a slightly different strategy. Until you document it you can’t flush out the nuance and subtlety that enables alignment to emerge from all of the many different interests, perspectives and world views that exist across your stakeholder community. Remember the first version is a DRAFT! Don’t worry if there are negative reactions or if new information is brought to light. That is actually the point. When we talk about things, our social behaviours come to the fore – we seek to affirm, support and agree. Once we see something written down it becomes an object we can discuss – you guessed it – objectively! Once ideas are tangible, we are better able to critique and explore them without feeling like we might upset someone. This is really important.

In addition to describing where you are, where you want to be, and what it takes to get there, you are also likely to capture your purpose, vision, values and even guiding principles that might help you along the way.

Wordsmith, Finesse and Refine

Wordsmithing often attracts bad publicity. We’ve all sat in meetings where senior leaders have focused on the missing comma rather than the critical change in direction being proposed. But this is one instance where wordsmithing is to be encouraged. Words have power, and if done well, your strategic plan will be with you for a few years. You will find some metaphors work and others won’t. You will find that some people want to be brazen and bold with the truth and others want to hint and imply. You will find some people find the word ‘agile’ exciting and others have an allergic reaction to it (like me :-). The same word or phrase can mean different things to different people, depending on their backgrounds and lived experiences. Somebody will think long term is five to ten years. Somebody else will think long term is 50-100 years.

All of these nuances are important, and working through them patiently helps to ensure that most people reading the strategic plan for the first time will take the same meaning from it as the one you intend.

Plan, Cull, and Launch

Once the verbal duelling is complete, it’s time to create the implementation plan. Remember that doing new things means stopping old things, unless you have an influx of new resources coming into the organisation. You will need to be brave and agree to stop things that people love. You will need to cancel projects and initiatives that have implications for people you care about. That is hard – as leaders it is one of the hardest things we do. But without it your new strategic plan will fail before it has even been launched.

Once you have a plan that has new activities, clarity about what is stopping, and resourcing allocated to the first things that need to get underway, you are ready to share your strategic plan with the world. And by world, I mean the people who care. Your staff, your stakeholders, your community, your investors, your clients, your cheerleaders and your greatest detractors.

With your strategic plan in place, you have a confident place to stand while you face the uncertain twists and turns that the world will inevitably send your way.

2 Responses

  1. What an amazing article! Just got goosebumps with inspiration and feeling a perfect time for reset! Thank you for this Rebecca!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *